Daily Archives: September 1, 2005

Or, how I learned to stop worrying and import the bugs. Hrrmmmm.

So my company’s looking at switching from using the beastly Bugzilla bug tracking software to using something called FogBugz. It seems a decent enough piece of software, though the install process went as follows:

1. Download and untar install files.
2. Learn from the readme that it requires a PHP extension, a daemon, and (for me) a PHP upgrade. This is all rather more intrusive than most bug software I’ve seen, though to be fair, Bugzilla also has a lot of dependencies.
3. Upgrade PHP.
4. Run a script at the command line to make sure dependencies are all worked out.
5. Start the daemon.
6. Run a wizard on the Web to set up the database, etc.
7. Buy and submit license key.
8. Worry about importing bugs from old bug tracker into new one.

This last item is the one that’s taken up some four hours of my morning today. FogBugz apparently ships as an asp application, but there’s a PHP version that we’re using. For the Windows version, there’s a script to import from Bugzilla, but it’s hosed on Linux. It seems to tap into stuff set in the PHP extension that’s Windows-specific or something. So I worked a little magic using some PEAR classes and was able to connect to Bugzilla’s xml interfact to retrieve bugs.

But I was getting authentication errors. Apparently, if you’re not logged in, you can’t see bugs using Bugzilla’s xml interface. I tried a couple of things and finally just used links at the command line with the -source flag to get all of our bugs as text files. I had to browse to our Bugzilla install using links and login first, though, so that the cookie would be set and subsequent connections would be able to see the xml data rather than the “NotPermitted” error.

So, now I’ve got 700ish bug reports in a directory. Time to hack the import script to make it work using my data rather than the obfuscated methods available through the Zend extension. This was just a little tedious and mainly consisted of finding objects and function calls and replacing them with arrays and keys that hold the corresponding data from my parsed xml. That is, the shipped code gets an xml file and creates objects to hold the data, while my code slurps in the xml and creates a nested array for each bug; I had to make the import script read my arrays rather than looking for objects. There were a couple of little hitches that were easily fixed, and before too long, I had my 700ish bugs imported into FogBugz.

But I noticed when reviewing my new bug list that I had a bunch of bugs that weren’t mine, and others had bugs that should have been mine. Moreover, most of the bugs were assigned to just two of us. Why this happened I have no idea. To fix it, I wrote a script that reconciles user ids between the two systems and changes bug assignment in FogBugz for each bug to what the assignment in Bugzilla originally was. For example, say user X in Bugzilla has numeric id 5, while he has numeric id 22 in FogBugz (just because of the way the users were imported). Luckily, both systems use the email address as the login, so I could query both databases, get the numeric id for each, and then do a query for each bug that says (in English) “Change the assigned-to field for bug 700 to the numeric id 22 because the numeric id for assigned-to in Bugzilla is 5, and user 5 in Bugzilla corresponds to user 22 in FogBugz because they map to the same email address.”

And voila, my bug list is as it should be. I’m sure we’ll find problems here and there, but by and large, I’d say it was as successful an import as could have been hoped for. Continue reading →